Hmmm, well yes, I suppose the Lotus is faster than the MX5 and some might say handles better, but is it as good?

Interesting review at http://www.carmagazine.co.uk/car-reviews/used-cars/icon-buyer-new-mazda-mx-5-vs-used-lotus-elise-car-november-2015-/

I like the summary:
It’s a dilemma best solved thus: only car? MX-5. Weekend toy? Elise.